
What’s your call?
| 1NT | ||||
| 2♣ | 2♦ | 2♥ | 2♠ | 2NT |
| 3♣ | 3♦ | 3♥ | 3♠ | 3NT |
| 4♣ | 4♦ | 4♥ | 4♠ | 4NT |
| 5♣ | 5♦ | 5♥ | 5♠ | 5NT |
| 6♣ | 6♦ | 6♥ | 6♠ | 6NT |
| 7♣ | 7♦ | 7♥ | 7♠ | 7NT |
| Pass | Dbl |
Stoppers in notrump – overrated or underrated?
Donn states plainly, “1NT. This is what my hand looks like.”
1NT by Weinstein who elaborates, “a touch light on stopper and a touch heavy on strength. Just like Goldilocks.”
Lee’s 1NT: “I want to show my approximate strength without going past 1NT, and we probably have a spade stopper anyway.”
Lawrence bids 1NT only after shopping the options. “Three possible choices: Double – negative, but without the four hearts partner will expect; 1NT – right on values, but no real spade stopper; 2♦ – a possible bid, but missing an expected fourth trump and more value than expected. There’s just too much to pass, although that could turn out to be the winner. I expect the panel to choose from among 1NT and 2♦. My choice, albeit with uncertainty, is 1NT.”
Cohen agrees. “Passing will only create further troubles. My lack of a true spade stopper is offset by the slight extra strength.”
Korbel: “1NT. This is a compromise between 2♠ and 2♦. If that makes sense to you, I have a doctor I can recommend.”
Rigal: “The negative double without hearts might work; but the simple 1NT call is about right for values, and if they have a big spade fit, they generally rescue me from my stupidity by bidding on in spades. I’m not a fan of 2♣, because over their spade raise, I have no idea what to do. Double is possible, but not this hand, I think.”
Meyers doubles despite having only three hearts, pleading compensating values. “Also, if partner has a spade stopper, I think notrump should be played from their side (1NT being my alternative call).”
Sanborn doubles and there is no second choice. “This is my break point for lying about number of hearts. I have too many points to pass and double is my least worst lie.”
Robinson’s “Rules of Being a Good Partner” will make riveting reading when he writes it someday. “Double. A good partner does not have four hearts. Even if partner does have four hearts, it could be a good contract.”
Shi tries 2♠. “It’s a toughie and I don’t expect I will score too well for this, but I think it’s probably right. The siding in notrump could be worth a trick or more. If partner has spade shortness, then my hand is a gold mine with 10 unwasted high-card points – something my partner will never play me for if I bid 1NT. And my spots are pretty good if we do play notrump.”
Colchamiro, who submitted this problem and who never feels strongly about anything, gets the last word. “1NT. Doubling with three cards in hearts over 1♠ never seems to pan out for me; some partners are so insistent! I just hate, hate, hate 2♣! What would partner do with: ♠x x ♥A Q x ♦A x x x x ♣K x x?
3♣ would be automatic, and how do you like your matchpoint chances there? That’s why, warts and all, I prefer 1NT, the least worst option. Even if they take the first five tricks, it’s probably not the end of the world. I know if I double and partner bids 1NT with ♠A–x–x, we’ll be better off positionally, but so be it. As for 2NT – puh-lease!”

